You Be the Photo Contest Judge/Part II: Birds « Arthur Morris/BIRDS AS ART

You Be the Photo Contest Judge/Part II: Birds

Hand Update

The left hand continues to improve every day. Both extension and flexion are at about 85%. The incisions healed perfectly. I got to thank Dr. Pouplolo yesterday and give him a goodbye hug. I thanked him and told him that I loved him but that I hoped that I never had to see him in his office again. He understood. He thought I was doing great and that the chance of re-infection was as close to zero as you can get (if I can say that without giving myself a kinehora).

You Be the Photo Contest Judge/Part II: Birds

Below are the second group of six images. You are invited to pick the three best images and rank them first, second, and third. The first person who matches my contest picks perfectly 1-2-3 will receive a $10 discount good on any item in the BAA On-Line Store. I will post the images that I deemed best in the Connecticut Seminar Contest in a few days. Have fun and good luck 🙂

(For older gear, the Shopper’s Guide links will take you to the current replacement.)

[Not a valid template]

Hawk Owl, Derby, VT. This image was created with the hand held Canon 100-400mm IS L zoom lens and the Canon XTi.

[Not a valid template]

Juvenile Rufescent Tiger Heron, Pipeline Road, Panama. This image was created with the hand held Canon 100-400mm IS L zoom lens and the Canon EOS-7D.

[Not a valid template]

Great Blue Heron, Bear Hole Reservoir, West Springfield, MA. This image was created with the tripod-mounted Canon 500mm f/4L IS lens, the 1.4X III TC, and the EOS-1D Mark IV: Gitzo GT3530LS Tripod with the Mongoose M3.6 Tripod Head.

[Not a valid template]

Flamingo, near, Disney World, Orlando, FL. Image created with the hand held Tamron 18-270mm lens (for Canon) hand held with the Canon EOS-40D.

[Not a valid template]

Osprey, Wellfleet, Cape Cod, MA. The image was created with the hand held Canon 100-400mm IS L zoom lens and the Canon EOS-7D.

[Not a valid template]

Short-eared Owl, Sachuest Point NWR, Middletown, RI. This image was created with the hand held Canon 500mm f/4L IS lens, the 1.4X III TC, and the EOS-1D Mark IV.

Please list the names of your 3 picks as follows:

1st:
2nd:
3rd:

As above, the first person who matches my contest picks perfectly 1-2-3 will receive a $10 discount good on any item in the BAA On-Line Store.

97 comments to You Be the Photo Contest Judge/Part II: Birds

  • 1st: Short-eared Owl
    2nd: Juvenile Rufescent Tiger Heron
    3rd: Great Blue Heron

  • 1. Hawk Owl
    2. Short Eared Owl
    3. Osprey

  • avatar Henry

    1st-Flamingo
    2nd-Short-eared Owl
    3rd-Hawk Owl

  • avatar edie_hinckley

    1. Osprey
    2. Hawk owl
    3. Flamingo

  • 1.) Short-eared Owl
    2.) Osprey
    3.) Flamingo

  • 1. Juvenile Rufescent Tiger Heron
    2. Short-eared Owl
    3. Hawk Owl

    Wonderful images everyone. Hope your hand gets better soon Artie.

    Dave

  • avatar Carl

    1. Short-eared owl

    2. Great Blue Heron

    3. Juvenile Rufescent Tiger Heron

  • avatar Esther Corley

    1. Short-eared owl
    2. Flamingo
    3. Hawk owl

  • avatar Gerry

    I’d be thrilled to have taken ANY of these; but, my order would be:

    1) Flamingo
    2) Hawk Owl
    3) Short Eared Owl

  • avatar Jon

    Great Blue Heron
    Tiger Heron
    Short Eared Owl

  • avatar Doug M

    1st – Short-eared Owl
    2nd – Flamingo
    3rd – Tiger Heron

  • avatar Steve Read

    #1 Great Blue Heron
    #2 Flamigo
    #3 Hawk Owl

  • avatar George Cottay

    1. Flamingo
    2. Great Blue Heron
    3. Short-eared Owl

  • 1 Hawk Owl
    2 Short-eared Owl
    3. Tiger Heron

  • avatar Mary Stamper

    1 Hawk Owl
    2 flamingo
    3 GB Heron

  • avatar Arla

    1. Flamingo
    2. Short eared owl
    3. Hawk Owl

  • avatar Peter Noyes

    1 Short Eared Owl
    2. Great Blue Heron
    3. Osprey

  • avatar Edward Fisher

    1.Flamingo
    2. Hawk Owl
    3.Tiger Heron

  • avatar Pat Dunnuck

    1. Short eared
    2. Flamingo
    3. Osprey

  • avatar Gerald Kelberg

    Nice challenge, maestro! Judging against my ideal, not my actual shots…
    1. Short-eared Owl – great impact and engages the viewer with both eyes
    2. Hawk Owl – charming image much to love in that expression, shame about the branch across the tail
    3. Flamingo – particularly liked the colour and the detail of the feathers, albeit some of the foreground feathers are a little soft – as it were!
    I liked colour and composition on the Tiger Heron very much but thought the head angle is a killer – I have plenty of grey heron shots of my own with OOF tip of the beak.
    The GBH is well exposed and I like the under wing detail, but the OOF branches kill it for me and I think i would prefer a more open wingspan if I could get it.
    The Osprey didn’t move me at all – strangely. Yes, I’d like it if it were mine, but the blacks seem a little blocked and the comp seems to draw attention to the OOF right wing.
    I hope the idea wasn’t to be very brief!
    Best wishes, Gerald

  • avatar Bill Richardson

    1. short eared owl
    2. hawk owl
    3. flamingo

  • 1st: Osprey
    2nd : Short eared owl
    3rd : Tiger Heron

  • avatar Eric Washburn

    1. Flamingo
    2. Short-eared owl
    3. Great blue heron

  • avatar Dena Proctor

    1st: Osprey
    2nd: Tiger Heron
    3rd: Great Blue Heron

  • avatar Charlie Young

    1.Flamingo
    2.Osprey
    3.Owl(short eraed)
    Glad the hand is on the mend.

  • avatar Pat Fishburne

    I am always amazed when I see read through the choices — and the order — that other people made! I just assume we’ll all agree — NOT!

    Short-eared owl

    Flamingo

    Hawk Owl (but I sure wish that stick weren’t there)

  • avatar Charlie Young

    My third pick was the short eared owl.

  • avatar Charlie Young

    1.Flamingo
    2.Osprey
    3.Owl
    Glad the hand is on the mend.

  • 1st-Short Eared Owl
    2nd-Tiger Heron
    3rd-Hawk Owl

    Great group of images but these are my picks as seen after looking for quite a while.

  • avatar Debby Clark

    Wow, that flamingo shot is awesome!

  • 1st-Short Eared Owl
    2nd-Tiger Heron
    3rd-Hawk Owl

  • avatar Debby Clark

    1. Tiger Heron — crisp, clear image; looks like he uses your Photoshop techniques.
    2. Great blue heron — crisp, clear image.
    3. Short-eared owl — now that’s a wow, to get it looking at the camera, and it’s pretty clear

    Glad your hand is better also! Wonderful blog; I share it with a bunch of folks.

  • avatar Arthur Morris/BIRDS AS ART

    Lou, How did you get an “L” on the end of your name?

    Ian, Thanks!

    Loren, That would be more than a bit of PS….

  • avatar Fran

    1. Short Ear Owl (the #6 image)
    2. Osprey
    3. Great Blue Heron

  • avatar Lou Newmanl

    1) Short-eared Owl
    2) Hawk Owl
    3) Osprey

  • avatar Nancy Bell

    1. Hawk Owl
    2. Tiger Heron
    3. Great Blue Heron

  • avatar Ian Anderson

    As someone who lives with chronic hand pain, I’m really happy to hear your surgery went so well.

    My picks:
    1. Hawk Owl (great expression, head angle, lighting, focus on eyes)
    2. Flamingo (good composition, use of color and light)
    3. Short-eared Owl (golden light, good focus on the eyes)

    Honestly 1 and 2 are a tossup and 3 is only because I find it the best of the rest, but I don’t think it’s as strong.

  • 1. Tiger Heron
    2. Great Blue Heron
    3. Flamingo

  • avatar Bill Dix

    1. Tiger Heron
    2. Hawk Owl
    3. Flamingo

  • avatar Odd Johan Lundberg

    1st:Short eared owl
    2nd:Flamingo
    3rd:tiger heron

  • avatar Jacques Bouvier

    The names of my 3 picks are as follows:

    1st: Short-eared Owl
    2nd: Great-blue Heron
    3rd: Osprey

    Jacques Bouvier

  • Glad the hand continues to improve. Even though you went through more than you should have had to, I think, in the long run, you dodged a bullet; you were (obviously) right to react and have it looked at as quickly as you did.

    1. Short Eared Owl
    2. Flamingo
    3. Hawk Owl (with a bit of PP to get the branch out from over the bird’s tail)

    Loren

  • avatar Paul Smith

    1st Short-Eared Owl
    2nd Osprey
    3ed Hawk Owl

  • avatar cheapo

    While not entering your comp, I would happily have wall sized versions of the Flamingo crop and the Great Blue Heron (with oof branch cloned out or a piece of furniture in front of it) in my house!And I lurrrve the characterful pose of the Hawk Owl.

  • avatar Dom Leone

    I think you’ve posted the flamingo before but still love it.

  • avatar Dom Leone

    The Tiger Heron just jumps out of the page at you/ WOW.

  • avatar Dom Leone

    These are all so good it gets harder and harder to pick. Anyway my choices are:
    1st Tiger Heron
    2nd Great Blue Heron
    3rd Flamingo

  • avatar Bob Malbon

    Tiger Heron
    N. Hawk Owl – (I have images of the same bird)
    Short-eared Owl

    Good luck with your hand – keep stretching!

    Bob Malbon

  • avatar Daya

    1) Flemingo
    2) Ospray and
    3) Short Eared Owl

  • Glad your hand is better. I’m sure I am not going to guess your choices but I like:

    1st- Tiger Heron
    2nd- Hawk Owl
    3rd- GBH w/o oof perch